NYPD Stops Act goes into effect — advocates hope for change within NYPD, by Oscar Fock

The How Many Stops Act, which includes a bill that requires New York Police Department officers to record the race, age and gender of the civilians they approach during investigative encounters, officially took effect on the first day of July. (The second bill requires the NYPD to report when a person denies consent to be searched.)

Previously, officers were only required to collect information during Level 3” encounters — a stop due to a reasonable suspicion that the individual has committed, is committing, or is about to commit a crime, during which officers have legal authority to detain or prevent the person stopped from leaving  — but will now have to also report Level 1 and 2 stops. A Level 1 stop is when police request information from a person without suspecting them of a crime, while a Level 2 stop means the officer has begun to suspect that the person has committed a crime.

The bill went through some political rigamarole earlier this year: After the city council passed the bill in December 2023, Mayor Eric Adams — a former member of the NYPD and a staunch supporter of the police department in his role as mayor — vetoed the bill, but on Jan. 30, the council overruled the mayors veto with a 42-9 vote.

Advocates for the bill say it is necessary to address over-policing of people of color. According to a 2023 report from the Federal Monitor, 97% of people stopped by the NYPDs Neighborhood Safety Teams were Black or Hispanic.

New Yorkers understand implicitly or explicitly that Black and Brown communities experience more policing. You see, hear, and feel it across the city. Yet the data for these critical interactions that hundreds of thousands of New Yorkers experience with the NYPD each year is far from complete”, Daniela Gilbert, director of the advocacy group Veras Redefining Public Safety initiative, wrote in an email. Vera is an organization that works to end overcriminalization and mass incarceration of people of color, immigrants and people experiencing poverty. New Yorkers deserve to have a full picture of how their encounters with law enforcement are represented and a full accounting of all NYPD stops and investigative encounters in our communities,” Gilbert added.

Alexa Avilés, council member for District 38 and a lead sponsor of the bill, noted that the communities most affected have been calling for a law like this for years.

The How Many Stops Act is common sense, good government policy. The data on Level 1 and 2 stops and consent searches collected via these two bills is an essential step toward developing much-needed policies with the goal of both protecting the constitutional rights of the public and uprooting long-standing and systemic issues within the department,” the council member wrote in an email.

Critics, including Mayor Adams, have primarily objected to including Level 1 stops in the new law. Earlier this year, the mayor said it would take too long to log the information, delaying police investigations. According to the police, the problem is the amount of Level 1 encounters — more than 3.2 million in 2022,  Michael Clarke, the departments director of legislative affairs, told the City Council in March of last year — and that such encounters often are fluid and fast moving. The Mayors Office of Criminal Justice and the New York Police Department did not respond to requests for comment for this story.

However, the many stops that go unreported is one issue that supporters hope the bill will address.

With such a staggering number of encounters between New Yorkers and NYPD going completely unreported, data trends that could affirm lived experience and help us craft good policy to protect our neighbors remain in the dark,” Gilbert wrote.

After the bill passed, the police department had about five months to develop the tools and strategies to record all levels of encounters. No details have been shared of what those tools and strategies look like, but during a July appearance on Mornings on 1,” Adams shared that the NYPD is prepared to comply with the new requirements, saying, As in any new initiative, there may be a few bumps along the way, but were going to do what the law calls for us to do. The time for me to raise my concern was raised. Now that its law, we will move forward. That is how were always going to operate.”

Avilés is critical of Adamss response to efforts to improve transparency and equitable treatment of the public within the NYPD.

 “The mayor took a spaghetti-at-the-wall approach to fearmongering around this legislation, hurling lies and producing propaganda at a breakneck pace. It would take days to refute each and every point, but Ill stick to one of the most irresponsible,” she wrote, adding, The administration regularly accused this effort as having a dangerous byproduct of bogging down officers with paperwork. I would ask detractors of the legislation to listen to the NYPDs own Deputy Commissioner, who in a PIX 11 interview on June 28, said implementation requiresminor policy operational changes. We didnt have to do much with technology. Just a tweak. 

Official numbers dont have to be made public until October (after which they will be shared on a quarterly basis), and the City Council has not received enough information from the police department as to how the new requirements are playing out, according to Avilés.

We are working to ascertain more details as to how implementation of the legislation is going,” she wrote in an email.

The new requirements can have implications beyond increased data collection of who is stopped by police in New York. Gilbert, whose organization Vera works across the country, highlights Denver as a city that used data to change its traffic stop policy.

Communities and legislators need to know what stops are the most common, need to take the social costs of policing seriously, and need policies and practices that will protect all residents, without over-policing Black and Brown people,” she said.

The How Many Stops Act, she said, is, therefore, not the destination; rather, its a step in the process of reducing the overreliance on policing to produce public safety.”

Author

  • Oscar Fock

    I’m a New York-based journalist from Sweden. I write about the environment, how climate change impacts us humans, and how we are responding.

    View all posts

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Comments are closed.

READ OUR FULL PRINT EDITION

click here to see our previous issues.

Our Sister Publication

a word from our sponsors!

Latest Media Guide!

Where to find the Star-Revue

Instagram

How many have visited our site?

wordpress hit counter

Social Media

Most Popular

On Key

Related Posts

Special birthday issue – information for advertisers

Author George Fiala George Fiala has worked in radio, newspapers and direct marketing his whole life, except for when he was a vendor at Shea Stadium, pizza and cheesesteak maker in Lancaster, PA, and an occasional comic book dealer. He studied English and drinking in college, international relations at the New School, and in his spare time plays drums and

PS 15’s ACES program a boon for students with special needs, by Laryn Kuchta

At P.S. 15 Patrick F. Daly in Red Hook, staff are reshaping the way elementary schoolers learn educationally and socially. They’ve put special emphasis on programs for students with intellectual disabilities and students who are learning or want to learn a second language, making sure those students have the same advantages and interactions any other child would. P.S. 15’s ACES

Big donors taking an interest in our City Council races

The New York City Council primary is less than three months away, and as campaigns are picking up steam, so are donations. In districts 38 and 39 in South Brooklyn, Incumbents Alexa Avilés (District 38) and Shahana Hanif (District 39) are being challenged by two moderate Democrats, and as we reported last month, big money is making its way into

Wraptor celebrates the start of spring

Red Hook’s Wraptor Restaurant, located at 358 Columbia St., marked the start of spring on March 30. Despite cool weather in the low 50s, more than 50 people showed up to enjoy the festivities. “We wanted to do something nice for everyone and celebrate the start of the spring so we got the permits to have everyone out in front,”