Message from Carlos: Resilient Together! by Carlos Menchaca

I’m proud of Red Hook. We get good results when we work together. In the last months, we looked to the future, learned from the past and planned a more resilient community.

Carlos making a campaign speech in Coffey Park.
Carlos Menchaca speaking in Coffey Park.

 

For example, at the Miccio Center, we learned about new ways of building integrated flood protection. People from all over Red Hook reaffirmed that resilience isn’t just about buildings and flood plans – it relies on people who know how to support each other. When city representatives came to propose a new street trolley or to ask for ideas about the planned citywide ferry service, we told them what Red Hook requires. If they’re smart, they’ll listen to us and make good decisions.

When bad city planning decisions of the past affected us, we responded with action. Lead contamination from old Red Hook factories requires a federally guided cleanup of the ball fields. We’ll lose precious recreational space for quite a while, but it will all come back better – and safer – than before. In the process, we established new ways of working with the Parks Department on community outreach.

When the restoration of our Sandy-damaged Senior Center was intolerably delayed, Red Hook seniors stood up and called for accountability and progress. I witnessed them change the way city government engages our community. Sometimes, it takes the wisdom of an older generation to put some sense in today’s city agency conversations.

Change is happening right before our eyes. Construction projects dot Red Hook, most of them “as of right,” meaning builders can proceed without City Council approval by using established zoning. Red Hook is changing for sure. Luckily, our community is more engaged than ever in determining how that change will take place.

Which brings me to a topic that’s been in the news recently, but was a year in the making – a large development proposed for 141 Conover Street. Last May, a private developer pitched an eight-story, for-profit, 200-bed nursing home west of Van Brunt in a mandatory flood evacuation zone. In this case, I knew I’d have the decisive voice on whether or not the project went forward because it depended on re-zoning historically heavy manufacturing property to residential use. Therefore, City Council oversight was triggered.

I took the decision to support or oppose this development very seriously. At many meetings beyond the required land use hearings, I listened to the developer, Red Hook residents, workers, resilience experts, and local business operators.

Weighing all the benefits and risks, the project proved to be unsafe and wrong for Red Hook’s long-term best interests.

It’s in a place where streets are often impassable, where public transit is distant, and where Hurricane Sandy knocked out power for five long weeks. It’s one thing to close an office or cancel shifts at a factory. Employees can stay home. Equipment can be replaced. But elderly patients there would be trapped if they sheltered in place, or traumatized if forced to evacuate.

I also saw this development’s placement as directly contrary to our community’s resilience planning. We all know Red Hook needs better access to health services and more facilities for the long-term care of elderly people with severe medical needs. We all want smart investment in our community, and to preserve Brooklyn jobs. The general benefits of nursing facilities are obvious. But the risks to patients and workers on Conover Street were not acceptable.

In short, I could not support placing nursing home patients and their caregivers in danger.

And so, in the City Council, I led the decision to deny the developer’s rezoning application. In today’s Brooklyn, in our Red Hook, essential medical services and the jobs they produce must be sited intelligently. If we fail to make good decisions that support resilience, future Red Hook residents will be forced to take action correcting our failures.

Carlos Menchaca is the City Councilmember for the 38th District, which includes Red Hook

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Comments are closed.

On Key

Related Posts

An ode to the bar at the edge of the world, theater review by Oscar Fock

It smells like harbor, I thought as I walked out to the end of the pier to which the barge now known as the Waterfront Museum was docked. Unmistakable were they, even for someone like me maybe particularly for someone like me, who’s always lived far enough from the ocean to never get used to its sensory impressions, but always

Millennial Life Hacking Late Stage Capitalism, by Giovanni M. Ravalli

Back in 2019, before COVID, there was this looming feeling of something impending. Not knowing exactly what it was, only that it was going to impact the economy for better or worse. Erring on the side of caution, I planned for the worst and hoped for the best. My mom had just lost her battle with a rare cancer (metastasized

Brooklyn Bridge Rotary Club returns to it’s roots, by Brian Abate

The first Brooklyn Rotary Club was founded in 1905 and met in Brooklyn Heights. Their successor club, the Brooklyn Bridge Rotary Club, is once again meeting in the Heights in a historic building at 21 Clark Street that first opened in 1928 as the exclusive Leverich Hotel. Rotary is an international organization that brings together persons dedicated to giving back