Menchaca Statement on Valentino Pier Bathrooms

I heard a variety of views during recent community meetings and conversations on the proposed comfort station at Valentino Pier Park. Some expressed the strong need for a bathroom in that area while others described issues with the comfort station as proposed.  Ultimately, I have decided to pull the funding from this currently proposed project.  

Carlos Menchaca speaking about Valentino Pier at the Red Hook Library
Carlos Menchaca speaking about Valentino Pier at the Red Hook Library

The roughly $2 million in New York City Council funds that were set aside for this comfort station during the previous administration will remain in Red Hook for a parks project.  The allocation of these funds will be built into our participatory budgeting process. More information on Participatory Budgeting in New York is available at http://www.pbnyc.org, and information on our neighborhood assemblies is available at http://council.nyc.gov/html/pb/events.shtml#district38.

This outcome does not change the fact that we need restrooms near Valentino Pier Park. A diverse group of stakeholders—including small businesses, those that fish off of the pier, kayakers, and Red Hook public housing residents—have underscored the real need for bathrooms in this area.  Let’s not forget that.

This comfort station project was inherited by both the New York City Council and the Parks Department.  My predecessor had allocated most of the funding to this Red Hook project over several years.  My office and the Borough President’s Office each contributed $250,000 to fill a gap in project costs that came from new FEMA requirements post-Sandy.  When we stepped in, the assumption was that this idea was borne out of a community process, but what we learned was a real need to press the re-set button and begin a new, truly participatory process.  This is a process I am committed to for capital projects and policy making across our district, and I hope you will all join me for the Participatory Budgeting kick-off TONIGHT (Sunset Park High School, 6:30PM), where I will discuss that vision with our community in more detail, and at the community assemblies that follow through the month of November.

Through conversations with the Parks Department, we all learned a tremendous amount about their process, and saw a real responsiveness to our initial ideas about scale and placement of the bathroom with the second proposal presented to us.  These are the types of conversations with our City agencies that we want to build upon, and I thank the Parks Department and the many community groups and individuals that participated in this productive conversation.

We heard a number of alternative ideas–from public-private partnerships on sites near the park to a model used in Portland (the Portland Loo) which would allow for restrooms at a much smaller scale. I am exploring some of these alternatives, with neighborhood groups and the Community Board, and the participatory budgeting process is the perfect way to keep this conversation going.

Finally, investments in our community should not be made in a vacuum–we must consider both residents and visitors when we spend capital dollars in our community.  This is a principle I am mindful of as we look at our entire capital process, including our participatory budgeting dollars.

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Comments are closed.

On Key

Related Posts

An ode to the bar at the edge of the world, theater review by Oscar Fock

It smells like harbor, I thought as I walked out to the end of the pier to which the barge now known as the Waterfront Museum was docked. Unmistakable were they, even for someone like me maybe particularly for someone like me, who’s always lived far enough from the ocean to never get used to its sensory impressions, but always

Millennial Life Hacking Late Stage Capitalism, by Giovanni M. Ravalli

Back in 2019, before COVID, there was this looming feeling of something impending. Not knowing exactly what it was, only that it was going to impact the economy for better or worse. Erring on the side of caution, I planned for the worst and hoped for the best. My mom had just lost her battle with a rare cancer (metastasized

Brooklyn Bridge Rotary Club returns to it’s roots, by Brian Abate

The first Brooklyn Rotary Club was founded in 1905 and met in Brooklyn Heights. Their successor club, the Brooklyn Bridge Rotary Club, is once again meeting in the Heights in a historic building at 21 Clark Street that first opened in 1928 as the exclusive Leverich Hotel. Rotary is an international organization that brings together persons dedicated to giving back