In the five years that we have been publishing the Star-Revue, we have been to countless meetings where beleaguered public housing tenants have pointed out, complained, and begged to have their living conditions improved.

Here's the information that was gathered at the silly meeting.
Here’s the information that was gathered.

From mold, to poor lighting, to cracks in walls, to broken refrigerators and rotting kitchen cabinets, broken mailboxes and front door locks, we’ve heard it all.
And guess what – it didn’t cost us a penny to find this information out. All we did was to keep our ears open at meetings and to people explaining to us the conditions they had to live in.

And before you think that this is OK – that living in public housing is a free ride – understand that NYCHA is very strict about collecting the rent – sending out eviction notices regularly. Tenants pay 30% of their GROSS income for the rent. In the old days, before NYC declared $1900 monthly rents to be “affordable,” this was considered the norm for all of us.

Another way for the average simpleton to understand the problems that public housing tenants face was to pay attention to the campaign speeches of the current mayor. Or to read Scott Stringer’s reports. Or to ask any Tenant Association president. Or to read the Daily News.

Both Lillie Marshall and Bea Byrd gave up a perfectly nice summer evening to take part in this session.
Both Lillie Marshall and Bea Byrd gave up a perfectly nice summer evening to take part in this session.

For some reason, NYCHA has decided that none of these methods is enough to understand the needs of their tenants. Instead, they decided to hire a trio of high-priced international consultants to hold an inane meeting at the Miccio Center, wasting our time and the city’s money to find out nothing new.

Kohn, Pederson, Fox is an international design firm that builds projects in places such as Malaysia, China and South Africa. They publish a glossy annual report that defines them as “an independent firm of planners, designers, engineers and consultants working across the built environment.”

ARUP is the second consultant. Their annual revenue is quoted in billions of British pounds. The third consultant for this project is OLIN. They are yet another global company. They are an architecture and design firm with government contracts throughout the US and Europe.

The people who showed up were cordoned off into little groups and asked some dumb questions.
The people who showed up were cordoned off into little groups and asked some dumb questions.

These companies sent out a slew of youngish looking employees to facilitate what was billed as “The Red Hook Houses Community Workshop.” Posters were put up all over the Houses and quite a number of curious residents came out to the meeting, which was held at the Miccio Center on a hot summer evening last July 21st.

In the old days, community meetings meetings meant that the people holding the meeting would sit or stand in front of an audience, with everyone being offered a chance to speak in front of the group.

These are the new days. Instead of allowing people to let everyone know what they think (which was once an important part of the democratic process), people are herded into many small groups. This not only keeps the meetings lashed to a pre-arranged script, but also gives work for more “facilitators.”

Each consultant follows the pre-arranged script in order to come up with a report containing mostly useless information that probably could have been written without having a meeting at all. However, these meetings are very profitable for the facilitators, so they must do this.

The inane questions asked that night included things like: “Do you use the outdoor areas of the Red Hook Houses? If so, which ones.” And: “is there adequate parking around your building?” And: “what do you like most about the open space around your home.”

Here are two of the interlocuters that came over from Manhattan to find out what is wrong with living in public housing.
Here are two of the interlocuters that came over from Manhattan to find out what is wrong with living in public housing.

An answer to the last question, as illustrated in the photo at the beginning of this editorial was “I Like Grass and Trees.”
We asked a woman after the meeting why they came to the meeting and what they thought of it. She told us that she came out of curiousity but would never waste her time again.

As she said this, some of the facilitators could be seen leaving the Miccio in a shiny black Uber mini-van, no doubt returning to their shiny glass walled Manhattan offices to write up their report, letting NYCHA know that their tenants like green grass and don’t like being held up at night. For this they are paid handsomely, being the international consultants that they are.

And then NYCHA has the nerve to complain about not having enough money to fix cracks in the walls.

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

2 Comments

  1. BULLSEYE GEORGE…
    I RESULT AND AGREE WITH YOUR ANALYSIS. ..
    THANK YOU

  2. gbrook@pipeline.com

    Not my analysis – that’s what everybody (including you) was saying afterwards. They ought to be paying us for giving them work to do! Or maybe they should just use common sense and hire someone to make sure the repairs are done properly, and come to a TA meeting like everyone else and see what improvements people are asking for. Or, like I said, read the Daily News.

On Key

Related Posts

The People of Red Hook asks the existential question of the day by Lisa Gitlin

By now, the community meeting on the future of the Brooklyn Marine Terminal, the 122-acre waterfront property running from Atlantic Avenue to Wolcott Street has taken place. There is more about this meeting and the NYC Economic Development Corporation (EDC) process inside these pages. As my publisher has pointed out in his column last month, this decision made by the

Working to protect neighbors from ICE, by Laryn Kuchta

District 38 Council Member Alexa Avilés knows how hard the Trump administration’s immigration policy is hitting Red Hook. Avilés, who is Chair of the Immigration Committee, says that community providers have noted drops in undocumented people accessing services and a lot of talk about moving away. People do not feel safe, according to Avilés. “There’s unfortunately an enormous amount of vitriol

Year of the Snake celebrated at Red Hook school by Nathan Weiser

PS 676/Harbor Middle School had another family fun night on January 28 after school in their cafeteria. The theme was Lunar New Year. Lunar New Year began on January 29, which marked the arrival of the year of the snake. The Lion Dance is performed during Lunar New Year as well as iconic firecracker ceremony. There was Chinese food and

Column: Since the community doesn’t seem to have much sway on the future of the Brooklyn Marine Terminal, the courts beckon, by George Fiala

Money and politics often get in the way of what economists call “The Public Good.” Here is Wikipedia’s  definition: “In economics, a public good (also referred to as a social good or collective good) is a good that is both non-excludable and non-rivalrous. Use by one person neither prevents access by other people, nor does it reduce availability to others.